The Rainmaker Blog – Building People, Leaders, Teams & Economic Moats

How to Overcome the Five Dysfunctions of a Team | Rainmaker Group

Written by Chris Young - The Rainmaker | Dec 29, 2021, 3:35:09 PM

Updated: November 11, 2026

To overcome the Five Dysfunctions of a Team, CEOs and their management teams must build vulnerability-based trust, debate ideas, commit to clear decisions, hold one another accountable, and prioritize collective results. These are the connected concerns in Patrick Lencioni’s Five Dysfunctions of a Team framework.

The next question is what keeps the dysfunction in place.

A management team can agree to communicate openly while the organization rewards withholding bad news. Managers can commit to shared priorities while departmental targets pull them in different directions. Accountability can remain dependent on the CEO because responsibility and decision authority do not match.

Those conditions require more than another conversation.

The Five Dysfunctions names the pattern. Rainmaker examines the organizational design that keeps producing it.

Organizational design includes who owns outcomes, who can make decisions, how disagreements are resolved, what the organization rewards, and which issues require CEO intervention. It is more than an organizational chart.

The work is to address the dysfunction without leaving those conditions untouched.

 

What Are the Five Dysfunctions of a Team?

Lencioni’s model describes five connected breakdowns in teamwork:

Dysfunction

What it means

Absence of trust

Team members resist showing vulnerability, including admitting mistakes, acknowledging limitations, or asking for assistance.

Fear of conflict

Artificial harmony replaces productive disagreement about ideas and decisions.

Lack of commitment

Insufficient clarity or buy-in prevents the team from committing to decisions.

Avoidance of accountability

Team members avoid challenging peers about agreed behaviors or performance.

Inattention to results

Individual interests, status, or departmental priorities displace collective success.

Trust forms the foundation of the model. It supports productive conflict, which contributes to commitment, accountability, and collective results.
 

Five disciplines for leadership teams, adapted from Patrick Lencioni’s Five Dysfunctions of a Team. Rainmaker examines the decision authority, outcome ownership, and operating rules that support—or undermine—these disciplines.

Rainmaker adds a structural inquiry: What makes each breakdown possible—and what allows it to continue?

For example, avoided accountability warrants more than a request for stronger follow-through. Examine whether the commitment was clear, whether its owner had sufficient authority, and whether the same standards applied to everyone.

Structure does not excuse individual misconduct or remove personal responsibility. It establishes the conditions within which responsibility must operate.

Try This Exercise 

Choose one recent management team issue. Answer four questions:

  • Where is our management team experiencing recurring dysfunction?
  • What is it costing in delayed decisions, rework, missed commitments, or lost productivity?
  • Who experiences the consequences—customers, employees, other departments, or the CEO?
  • What specific example occurred in the past 30 days, and what happened?

For that example, identify the outcome owner, the relevant decision authority, the competing priorities, and the point at which progress stalled.

Separate what you observed from what you assume.

“People need to communicate better” is an interpretation. “Three managers believed someone else owned the decision” is a condition that can be examined.

 

1. Ask Yourself: Is This Another Book for the Bookshelf or a Real Turning Point?

Reading the book creates a shared vocabulary. It does not change how the management team operates.

A turning point requires identifying which recurring situations must work differently.

Consider a management team that debates a decision, reaches agreement, and assigns an owner. The following day, a private conversation with the CEO reverses the decision without informing the team.

The problem is not simply weak commitment. The organization has no reliable rule for when a decision becomes final or how it can be reconsidered.

The architectural change is to define decision ownership, the conditions for reopening decisions, and how changes are communicated. The CEO must operate within those rules as well.

A commitment to improve is not a substitute for changing the conditions that undermine the commitment.

 

2. Use Experienced Facilitation to Surface the Constraints

Determine what needs examination before deciding which tool or facilitator to use.

External facilitation can be useful when the CEO needs to participate fully, disagreements remain unspoken, or the team struggles to examine its own assumptions. It is an input into the work—not proof that the underlying problem has been resolved.

Use the discussion to investigate actual events. Where was a concern withheld? Which disagreement remained unresolved? What prevented a manager from challenging a missed commitment?

Connect vulnerability-based trust and productive conflict to the conditions under which people make decisions and raise concerns.

If disagreement is encouraged publicly but penalized privately, a better discussion leaves the contradiction intact.

Facilitation can expose the breakdown. Changes to authority, standards, and operating rules address the conditions surrounding it.

 

3. Use Individual Assessments as Inputs, Not a Complete Diagnosis

Individual assessments and a team assessment answer different questions.

Information about behavioral preferences, values, and individual differences can inform how managers understand one another. It does not establish whether their roles are properly designed.

Consider two managers who repeatedly disagree about customer commitments. Different communication preferences may affect the discussion. But if both believe they have final authority over delivery dates, the dispute also contains an unresolved decision-rights problem.

Calling it a personality clash leaves that problem untouched.

Use individual assessment information alongside explicit role expectations, responsibilities, and authority boundaries. Select an instrument according to the question it can credibly answer—not because an assessment is assumed to be the first step in every engagement.

Assessments provide inputs. They do not redesign roles, assign authority, or resolve conflicting expectations.

 

4. Complete The Five Dysfunctions Team Assessment Report

The Five Dysfunctions Team Assessment provides feedback across the model’s five areas. Its report can establish a baseline for discussing the team’s perceived strengths and gaps.

Use the results to focus the investigation.

A low accountability score does not establish a single cause. Expectations may be unclear. Managers may avoid challenging peers. Some commitments may sit outside the owner’s authority. Different situations require different responses.

Connect the feedback to recent decisions, disagreements, and missed commitments. The CEO should participate in that examination rather than treat the report as an evaluation of everyone else.

For a deeper discussion, see how to act on your Five Dysfunctions Team Assessment results.

A repeat assessment at six to nine months is one possible review point. It is not a completion deadline or a reason to postpone correcting known problems. Compare any change in scores with evidence from the team’s actual work.

5. Slow Down to Speed Up: Test Changes in How the Team Operates

The duration of a meeting does not establish whether an organization has changed.

After identifying a constraint, define the relevant change and test it in the situations where the breakdown occurs.

Consider a company where sales commits to customer deadlines while operations controls capacity. When their priorities collide, every disagreement reaches the CEO.

Telling both managers to collaborate more effectively leaves the decision unresolved.

The design needs to specify who can make delivery commitments, what information must inform those commitments, and which exceptions require escalation. Shared performance measures should not reward one function for creating problems in another.

Then examine whether the revised arrangement works under pressure.

This does not always require changing reporting lines. It may require changing decision authority, shared measures, or cross-functional responsibilities.

The objective is not another session. It is a different result when the same situation returns.

 

6. Create a Team Playbook for Norms, Communication, and Accountability

A management team playbook should record how the team operates—not only how its members prefer to communicate.

Retain useful communication preferences, team commitments, norms, individual strengths, development needs, and meeting standards. Then document the operating decisions that make those commitments workable.

Playbook component What it must clarify
Outcome ownership Who is accountable for each shared outcome, and how success is evaluated.
Decision authority Which decisions each manager can make, who must be consulted, and what remains with the CEO.
Disagreement and escalation How peers resolve competing priorities and when escalation is appropriate.
Decision continuity How decisions are recorded, communicated, and reconsidered when circumstances change.
Shared results Which company-wide measures govern trade-offs between departments.

The First Team principle emphasizes commitment to the leadership team’s collective responsibilities rather than allegiance only to a department.

That commitment needs a corresponding operating design. Managers need a defined way to resolve departmental trade-offs and measures that support company-wide outcomes.

The playbook records the design. Writing the document does not replace making the design decisions.

 

7. Stay Committed: Review Decisions, Accountability, and Results

Use 30-, 60-, and 90-day checkpoints to examine whether the changes are working. Treat these as review opportunities, not guaranteed milestones.

Look at decisions that stalled, commitments that were missed, and issues that repeatedly returned to the CEO. Determine whether the cause was an unclear expectation, an authority gap, an unresolved priority conflict, or a failure to fulfill an explicit responsibility.

Keep useful feedback practices, including the 3-3-1 format: three things going well, three things not going well, and one area requiring support. The 3-3-1 feedback template can be adapted to the management team’s work.

Reporting an issue is not the same as resolving it. Each material issue still needs an owner and a clear route to a decision.

Review escalation carefully. Fewer escalations are not progress if managers are concealing problems or making decisions outside their authority.

Execution routines create a review rhythm. They do not substitute for correcting the design issues the review exposes.

 

8. Keep Reading - and Use the Framework as a Shared Language

The CEO and every management team member should understand The Five Dysfunctions of a Team well enough to apply its distinctions to actual situations.

Use the book to distinguish productive disagreement from personal conflict, commitment from superficial agreement, and accountability from CEO enforcement. Continue the discussion with Patrick Lencioni’s The Advantage.

Reading supports shared understanding. It is not evidence that the organization has changed.

The evidence is in what happens when the management team must make a difficult decision, challenge a colleague, or resolve competing priorities.

 

Frequently Asked Questions About Overcoming the Five Dysfunctions of a Team

How can CEOs and their management teams overcome the Five Dysfunctions of a Team? 

Address the dysfunction and the organizational conditions that sustain it. Start with specific examples of unclear decisions, avoided disagreements, missed commitments, or conflicting priorities. Identify who owns the outcome, who has authority, and where progress requires CEO intervention. Use Lencioni’s framework to understand the breakdown, then determine what must change in how the management team operates. Agreement to improve does not resolve unclear authority or incompatible responsibilities.

Why does management team dysfunction return after a workshop?

A workshop can change understanding without changing the conditions under which the team operates. Consider managers who commit to company-wide results while their departmental targets continue to reward competing priorities. The agreement has changed; the incentives have not. Examine the mismatch between what the team says matters and what the organization requires, rewards, or tolerates. Facilitated conversations can expose that mismatch. They do not automatically resolve it.

Should a management team address trust before accountability?

Trust is foundational in Lencioni’s model, supporting productive disagreement, commitment, and peer accountability. That does not mean suspending performance standards until everyone feels comfortable.

Examine whether managers can question unrealistic commitments, acknowledge mistakes, and challenge peers under consistent standards. If some managers are protected from challenge, asking everyone to be more accountable leaves the exception intact. Address trust while clarifying commitments, authority, and how missed expectations are handled.

What should a CEO and management team do with their Five Dysfunctions Team Assessment results?

Use the results to identify questions that require investigation—not to declare a complete diagnosis. Connect the feedback to recent decisions, disagreements, and missed commitments. A low accountability score should prompt examination of whether expectations are explicit, managers have sufficient authority, and peers address missed commitments directly. Include the CEO in that examination. The assessment provides a starting point; it does not establish why the problem exists or which changes are required.

How can a management team build accountability without relying on the CEO to enforce every commitment?

Define outcomes, decision authority, shared standards, and escalation rules. Managers should know which decisions they own, which disagreements they must resolve together, and which matters require the CEO. The CEO must uphold those boundaries rather than bypass them through private exceptions. Management team members must address commitments within their authority instead of routing every difficult conversation upward. This preserves necessary executive oversight while locating routine accountability within the management team.

What should a management team playbook include beyond communication preferences?

Include outcome owners, decision authority, shared measures, cross-functional responsibilities, and rules for resolving disagreements or reconsidering decisions. Communication preferences and meeting norms remain useful, but they do not establish who decides when agreement does not emerge. A commitment to company-wide results also needs a defined way to resolve competing departmental priorities. The playbook should document those decisions—not use broad statements about teamwork in place of them.

How can a CEO and management team tell whether they are overcoming team dysfunction?

Examine recurring decisions, commitments, and results—not only the tone of meetings. Are concerns raised before decisions? Do commitments have clear owners? Do managers address missed expectations with one another? Are competing priorities resolved through defined authority? Review escalation as well: routine issues should be resolved at the appropriate level, while material risks still reach the CEO. Assessment scores provide another perspective, but operating evidence shows whether the team handles its previous failure points differently.

How does The Rainmaker Group approach the Five Dysfunctions of a Team?

The Rainmaker Group uses Lencioni’s framework to examine management team dysfunction within the organization’s broader design. Trust, conflict, commitment, accountability, and results provide language for identifying the breakdown. Rainmaker then examines how authority, outcome ownership, incentives, and cross-functional responsibilities contribute to the pattern.

Assessments and facilitated discussions are inputs. Structural redesign is the mandate. The objective is a management team that can own decisions, address commitments, and pursue collective results without requiring constant CEO intervention.

 

Where Does the Business Slow Down Without the CEO?

When the same decisions, disagreements, and missed commitments repeatedly return to the CEO, examine the system that makes that intervention necessary.

The Rainmaker Group redesigns organizational systems so management teams can own decisions, address commitments, and pursue collective results without making the CEO the permanent point of escalation.

Organizations produce exactly what they are designed to produce.

Discuss the structural constraint with The Rainmaker Group.

 

More Five Dysfunctions of a Team content: 
 
What are the Five Dysfunctions of a Team and Why Do They Matter?
Mastering the 'First Team' Principle: An Essential Guide for Leaders Serious About Scaling Their Business
Five Dysfunctions of a Team Exercises
Five Dysfunctions of a Team Conflict Resolution Model
Five Dysfunctions of a Team Character Analysis
Five Dysfunctions of a Team Activities / Info
Idea Meritocracy at Apple: How Steve Jobs Fostered a Culture of Innovation

 

Chris Young is the founder of The Rainmaker Group. He works with CEOs and management teams to redesign the organizational systems that determine decisions, accountability, and performance.